PDA

View Full Version : 36" Walk Behind Input


leftnose
06-01-2010, 01:28 PM
So I've moved to a new home and the lot, about one acre, just takes longer than I'm willing with my ancient 21" pre-Briggs cast deck Toro.

I'm thinking of buying a 36" belt-drive Scag w/ 16hp Kawasaki. I've visited one dealer and was quoted a price of about $3.5K including the mulch kit. I know that a Scag is probably overkill for what I need and that I could do just fine with an equivalent Bobcat but I tend to like overkill. I figure that with my level of usage that a Scag will last basically forever with standard preventative maintenance.

However, any suggestions or input would be appreciated.

clean_cut
06-04-2010, 11:24 PM
I would also be interested on the better 36"

Leftnose, are you considering buying used? I'm sure there are may be some good deals on your local www.craigslist.org

lifetree
06-04-2010, 11:28 PM
I would also be interested on the better 36" ...

Yeah, you should consider a Quick 44" Dually for the same amount of money !!

DJJS
06-04-2010, 11:33 PM
So I've moved to a new home and the lot, about one acre, just takes longer than I'm willing with my ancient 21" pre-Briggs cast deck Toro.

I'm thinking of buying a 36" belt-drive Scag w/ 16hp Kawasaki. I've visited one dealer and was quoted a price of about $3.5K including the mulch kit. I know that a Scag is probably overkill for what I need and that I could do just fine with an equivalent Bobcat but I tend to like overkill. I figure that with my level of usage that a Scag will last basically forever with standard preventative maintenance.

However, any suggestions or input would be appreciated.

I've got both scag & bobcat walkbehinds as well as exmark, to be honest bobcat in my expierence is just as good as the others. It's much more reasonably priced as well. I'm not sure if you've ever used a commercial walkbehind before but you may want to try to get a demo of a scag and a bobcat, see which you're more comfortable with. Also, be prepared to have to muscle it from time to time.

mjealey
06-05-2010, 12:13 AM
I have a 36" Scag WB that is belt-driven. As a homeowner you are going to be using this mower once a week. I have found that with a belt-drive it doesn't take much for your hands to start hurting from squeezing the pistol grips. I do not know what your property looks like, but if you think you will be needing reverse a good bit, I would second guess a belt-drive as it is reverse "Assist" except the "Assist" part of it doesn't work if you are backing up on any kind of hill, and you are yanking a 450 lb. machine around. Trust me, it can get old. If you have the money and want one of the best mowers, go with a Scag. As a homeowner, you would probably like Bobcat or any other equivalent brand.

If I were you, I would check out the Snapper Pro SW20. It is a full hydro machine, and a floating deck that is easy to adjust the height. With the Scag you have to take the front casters off and adjust the amount of shims below and above the fork. Just something to think about. The Snapper Pro starts out at $3999 and would be perfect for you. Might be a little over what you want to pay. I would demo a belt-drive and a hydro if you could. There is a difference.

mjealey
06-05-2010, 12:15 AM
By the way, I got a deal on my Scag at the end of last year. It is a 2005 with the 15 HP Kohler. I only paid $800 for mine and it runs all day and night and I have made a lot of money with it. Scag and most other manufacturers have a good warranty for homeowners so that is something to think about.

ed2hess
06-05-2010, 06:37 PM
If I were you, I would check out the Snapper Pro SW20. It is a full hydro machine, and a floating deck that is easy to adjust the height. With the Scag you have to take the front casters off and adjust the amount of shims below and above the fork. Just something to think about. The Snapper Pro starts out at $3999 and would be perfect for you. Might be a little over what you want to pay. I would demo a belt-drive and a hydro if you could. There is a difference.

I second the Snapper Pro....it seems pretty solid and deck adjustment is nice and grease point easy to get to.

milkie62
06-05-2010, 11:06 PM
Believe me or not but if it is an easy not real steep property for the money you cannot beat a Craftsman lawn tractor.I am not kidding.I do some mower repair as a sideline and for the money especially if you get it on sale a 42" lawn tractor does a nice job.Parts availability is very good and generally there is a complete parts breakdown in the owners manual.Like I said if it is not beat on it will last with normal maintenance and if you wreck it after 4 or 5 yrs ,no big deal you would have gotten your money out of it and you can buy another new one at a reasonable price.

yardguy28
06-05-2010, 11:33 PM
I have a 36" Scag WB that is belt-driven. As a homeowner you are going to be using this mower once a week. I have found that with a belt-drive it doesn't take much for your hands to start hurting from squeezing the pistol grips. I do not know what your property looks like, but if you think you will be needing reverse a good bit, I would second guess a belt-drive as it is reverse "Assist" except the "Assist" part of it doesn't work if you are backing up on any kind of hill, and you are yanking a 450 lb. machine around. Trust me, it can get old. If you have the money and want one of the best mowers, go with a Scag. As a homeowner, you would probably like Bobcat or any other equivalent brand.

If I were you, I would check out the Snapper Pro SW20. It is a full hydro machine, and a floating deck that is easy to adjust the height. With the Scag you have to take the front casters off and adjust the amount of shims below and above the fork. Just something to think about. The Snapper Pro starts out at $3999 and would be perfect for you. Might be a little over what you want to pay. I would demo a belt-drive and a hydro if you could. There is a difference.

also keep in mind though that if the professionals can use these belt driven, reverse assist, pistol grip 450 lb. machines all day long 5 days week a homeowner can easily use one once a week for an hour or however long it would take you to mow.

i personally don't care for the gear driven (belt drive) as well as the hydro but when i first started my business it's what i used day in day out and it wasn't all that bad. i can tell you my hands have never hurt from using the pistol grip, it's not the greatest when things are damp or wet from dew or rain but since your homeowner you might be able to avoid mowing in damp or wet conditions and you can easily reverse the mower without using the reverse assist feature in the first place.

lifetree
06-06-2010, 12:18 AM
Believe me or not but if it is an easy not real steep property for the money you cannot beat a Craftsman lawn tractor. ...

Well OK ... I choose not to believe you !!

frotis
06-06-2010, 12:21 AM
You can get a 48" Exmark Metro with ECS controls for $3200, 48" is a good size for an acre.

Groh's Mows
06-06-2010, 12:23 AM
Look around, demo and/or test-drive as many mowers as you can. As the owner of the same sw36 16kai you are looking at, I can tell you the Scag is built to last and the Advantage deck cuts really well. Changing the heigth of cut probably is not a big factor if you cut at the same height every week.

Jpquinn99
07-09-2010, 07:47 PM
try to go used if you can. I got a used 36'' bobcat for $1750. Its a 2004 and in great shape