PDA

View Full Version : Diesel vs. Gas


jsr2741
10-29-2002, 06:31 PM
Does anyone have an opinion on when buying a ztr would you be ahead to buy one with a diesel or gas. I like the idea of more torque, less wear, and general reliability of a diesel but does it make sense to buy a machine were it will wear out long before the engine.

This was the response I got from my dealer. I've also asked some friends who work in road construction why their company doesn't use diesel powered pickup trucks. Their response was the same; we wear out the truck long before the engine and its just not feasible.

Any opinions.

Steve

Green Pastures
10-29-2002, 07:45 PM
Kubota has some nice diesel ZTR's.

Scott

sdwally
10-30-2002, 10:59 AM
If you compared the same size engines diesel's have more torque and usally less hp. Torque is what is need for powering through heavier loads. Turbos on diesels will increase the hp and torque ratings.
Diesel's are constructed heavier to handle high compression ratios. Gas engines typically operate at 125psi cylinder compression which is about an 8:1 compression ratio. Diesels operate at 300psi to 400psi which is about 32:1 compression ratio. That is why General Motor's first diesel which was gas engine block converted to diesel was a lemon. It could not handle the higher compression pressures.
Diesel fuel itself also contains much more available potential energy for doing work than the same amount of gasoline. As an example, with no load on the engine, at idle a diesel engine will use a teaspoon of fuel, let say the gas engine will use a teaspoon of fuel also. At no load and at full throttle, gasoline will use a cup of fuel, while the diesel will only use a few drops more than a teaspoon. However under heavy loads the diesel will increase its fuel consumption to about 3/4 of a cup. While the gas engine's fuel consumption under heavy loads stays the same.
Gasoline engines are constricted basically by the amount of the air/fuel mixture that the engine is able to get into to the cylinder, while diesel engines are only restricted by the amount of air(oxygen) in the cylinder during the ignition phase.
Diesel fuel is injected into the cylinder at the start of the ignition phase and for a period of rotation of the crank(longer period of fuel burn for more power). While gas engine has a spark to ignite the air/fuel mixture for a bang of power.
This makes diesel much more fuel economical in the long run. Also with diesel, there is no carb problems to worry about or any changing of plugs, wires, cap, and rotor on a regular basis.

Brickman
10-30-2002, 12:06 PM
The diesel engine option will cost more $$ to buy. Put pencil to paper to see if it will pay out in fuel savings over the expected life of the unit.

If I could make the numbers work, diesel would be the way I would go.

LakeSide Lawn and Landscape
10-30-2002, 01:00 PM
I think the deisel engines are too expensive on a mower.There are some great things about a diesel but not enough to compensate for the $$ difference..IMO! THANKS

Gravely_Man
10-30-2002, 03:03 PM
If and that is a big if I could afford it then I would go with a diesel hands down. They are great. Eric Elm was getting incredible amounts of time out of his diesel engines.

Gravely_Man

WREBELMACHINE
10-31-2002, 01:40 PM
I bought a diesel bladerunner last year and just bought a new bladerunner diesel to with it this year. For years I have been using gas engines but after the first diesel there is no comparision in fuel savings, power and the production between the two is incredible! Now I am not comparing the same brand of mowers but when you compare the engines there is a big diffrence! As far as longevity I personnally think if you find the right mower set up correctly you should be able to get 10,000+ hrs. out of the machine. Of course that is not considering employees!

Ricky
10-31-2002, 05:53 PM
I have the DC XWD-2600. I love mine. I burns about .8 gal of fuel and I almost always run dbls. I have several ac. that I cut about once a month without any problem (don't use dbls on these). Diesel is usually cheaper, but not at the moment. Not all the gas stations carry diesel so this is a little bit of a hassle. Diesels are heavier and will show it on wet ground but it gives you a smoother ride on rough property. Also consider that with it being water cooled, you will have more belts, hoses, and other things to keep an eye on. I have not replaced a belt or hose with over 700 hrs. yet, I know that that could happen any time.

When I was researching mowers, I kept seeing Eric Ericsons name about his Choppers and dependabality. That is how I met him on the web. He led me to this forum when he was the moderator here. I remember him talking about the hrs. that he had on his DC's. These were gas at the time. He was also looking into getting a diesel and said that "diesel is always better". Well, I got it and he got one the next month or two. It didn't take long for him to surpass the hrs. that I had on mine. As far as I know, he still liked his when he passed. I miss chatting with him about those Choppers.:(:(:( He enjoyed talking about them.:)

Good info sdwally!

dr grass
10-31-2002, 08:32 PM
diesel diesel diesel!!!! so you run the mower down before the motor pukes! so what!!! look at all the money you saved on fuel and repairs over the course of time you owned the thing!! daaaaa!!!!!


shep :eek:

cantoo
10-31-2002, 09:00 PM
If the diesel outlasts the mower then just get another mower take the gasser out sell it outright then drop the diesel in and back saving money.
I buy reel mowers with diesels in them and just resell them for the motors. Last year I bought two Buntons with Kubota diesels in them for Can$1100 they had around 1200 hrs on them. Made some good money. By the way our daily mowers are gas. :)

Bunton Guy
10-31-2002, 11:02 PM
The way I have seen it much of the time is alot of gas engines have engine failures way before the engine life is expired. Seems since diesel engines have less moving parts they actually live out there full life...I worked for a gold coarse for many years and 85% of equipment was diesels and they lived a full life....on the other hand gasser where always in the shop for repair and always ended their lives way before there expected life span....most lasted 1,200 hours on the gassers and 8-9K hours on diesel.

weve
11-01-2002, 12:24 AM
I also have the DC XWD2600-60. After the first year of use, I calculated the run time for several jobs compared to my previous mower--a DC XF2500-60 with Kohler engine. The Yanmar Diesel saved me between 6% and 13% in time per mowing. It just mows faster through heavy growth than with the Kohler engine.

The diesel also uses 1/3 less fuel than the gasoline engine.

jsr2741
11-02-2002, 01:29 PM
Thanks for the imput. Now all I have to do is figure out which one to buy. Looks like a lot of demoing this spring.

Thanks,

Steve

BladeRunner Rep
11-03-2002, 06:15 PM
jsr2471

Please give us a visit in the manufactures forum! Maybe we can arrange a demo for you sometime!