How much splash does it give off Bruce? 2 gallons on average sounds about right for a small pondless. Why are you questioning the water loss? I mean are you refilling every couple day's?
Just to be sure go back to the basics and check your edges etc. There has been a few times that "No way it's the side edges" and sure enough it was a low edge just sipping water out.
St.louis Ponds and Waterfalls
"We bring life to your backyard"