What did your guy actually do?
Sorry, to be blunt, $1,800 of whatever he got was probably the better end of the deal. If you're not aware, you received a $40 template
, no real on-site SEO, and a lazy attempt at site functionality. For example, clicking on your pictures just sends a visitor to a new page of only the .jpg and no navigation or info, requiring us to use our browser to get us back to your actual site. Also, your domain redirects from a .org to a .biz address once I click thru the site's navigation.