View Single Post
Old 06-14-2013, 09:05 PM
AWJ Services AWJ Services is offline
LawnSite Platinum Member
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Ga
Posts: 4,273
Originally Posted by ksss View Post
Yes it does have a bearing on ownership costs.

Here is an example of a recent purchase.

I bought a new CASE 440 wheeled machine in 06. The machine had cab, heat, no AC, no high flow but ride control and aspirator and other small adds. Price 36K.

I traded this machine in Fall of 2012 with 2000K hours on it. It was in decent shape. They showed me 25K with VTS which they itemized a value of $2250. I traded that machine on a 2012 TR320 CTL. Completely loaded including both high flow systems, ride control, EH, cab/heat/air. It cost me my machine with the VTS and 25K.

The purchase price was just over 50K for the new machine. If you do the math here is what it says. The value of my 440 after 6 years was $22750. Subtract purchase price and you get $13250. Breaking it down a little further, it cost me $2208 a year in depreciation or about $6.50 an hour. Conversely I have run numbers on some CAT MTL's and found numbers as high as $50 an hour.

I swapped into the 320 for 25K complete with all the benefits of a new machine and a dedicated CTL (or about the price of a good used machine).

I realize that trades make it tough to see true value due to front or back loading of the deal. However seeing the price of the 320 and the value of the 440 its easy to see it was not a front or back loaded deal.

I hope this illustrates what decent trade value can mean to an owner especially year after year and purchase after purchase. I can run new equipment for the price of a good used machine.

I do agree that purchasing just on resale value is not correct, also I am not advocating CASE equipment. I use them as an example simply because that is what I run, and I have the numbers. Across all lines combined, CAT traditionally has the best resale and I don't own anything CAT. I believe it is a balance that needs to be struck. However it is certainly not irrevelent.

I only brought all this up because the OP said his dealer would only give him 10K on his machine with 750 hours on it. Granted I don't know what year the Gehl is or anything about it, but to only be offered 10k on it (assuming its in decent shape), would ensure that I would not own that color again. Hence the comment which kicked all this off.

I like being able to roll into a new machine without having to start over on the purchase price, which is what you end up doing by running machines until they have no value or buying machines that dont hold their new purchase price very well.

You paid 36k added 15k worth of VTS and are happy too get 22k? Not good resal value in my opinion and I am not taking into account maint. take 2000 hours and divide that into 30k plus and that is 15 dollars an hour depriciation min. Not figuring interest or sales tax into the equation.
Reply With Quote
Page generated in 0.04355 seconds with 8 queries