Organic Supplements Effectiveness

[kennc38]

Originally Posted by Smallaxe

This post should only be offensive to those who refuse to acknowledge the importance of "Understanding' what constitutes the building of soils or even benefitting the roots... If the OP is interested in understanding which products, for which conditions, then he'd have something to offer the NEWBIES...

Originally Posted by Smallaxe

This bashing and condescension is becoming a law unto itself...
If I'm not responding correctly to the OP, then YOU show me how its done... Why are you talking to me anyways??? I have no reason to talk to you...

I agree, this bashing needs to stop. As you will note in your bolded quote above, you bashed the OP by saying he needs to be interested in what YOU feel he needs to be interested in. Again, you haven't responded to Kiril's points above...interesting... If you have no reason to talk to me, then please stop responding to my posts. Thanks, friend...

[phasthound]

[QUOTE=Smallaxe;4657830]Why are you talking to me anyways???

Good question.

[Smallaxe]

To the OP:

I added 'humates' to the lawns of an HOA development, that was built on an abondoned coal mining operation,,, and the humates did nothing... therefore the Humates are useless for soils all across the continent...

I added fish emulsion to dried up lakebeds made into lawns and gardens, but again,,, NO improvement... therefore fish emulsion has nothing to offer any soil within the continental US...

I even added pulverised rock dust to lawns build on the Kettle Morrain here in Wisco, but it had no affect or showed any improvement whatsoever,,, therefore Rock Dust is worthless...

If you believe that I'm bashing you,,, then I certainly apologize... my point was simply a point that is common to normal discussion,,, in that questions provide context for basic contextualization of the question being presented...
Here's another question that may privide some context... : Would CT help my clay covered lawn here on the Morriane??? What if I'm stuck with the Sandy part of Glacial Wash??? Would the results be the same???

It DOES matter... if everyone wants to believe that it does not matter, and attack me for framing the questions in a CONTEXT,,, then so be it...

[Kiril]

Originally Posted by Smallaxe

This bashing and condescension is becoming a law unto itself...

And yet you do it in nearly every post you make.

[Weekend cut easymoney]

Originally Posted by Smallaxe

To the OP:

I added 'humates' to the lawns of an HOA development, that was built on an abondoned coal mining operation,,, and the humates did nothing... therefore the Humates are useless for soils all across the continent...

I added fish emulsion to dried up lakebeds made into lawns and gardens, but again,,, NO improvement... therefore fish emulsion has nothing to offer any soil within the continental US...

I even added pulverised rock dust to lawns build on the Kettle Morrain here in Wisco, but it had no affect or showed any improvement whatsoever,,, therefore Rock Dust is worthless...

If you believe that I'm bashing you,,, then I certainly apologize... my point was simply a point that is common to normal discussion,,, in that questions provide context for basic contextualization of the question being presented...
Here's another question that may privide some context... : Would CT help my clay covered lawn here on the Morriane??? What if I'm stuck with the Sandy part of Glacial Wash??? Would the results be the same???

It DOES matter... if everyone wants to believe that it does not matter, and attack me for framing the questions in a CONTEXT,,, then so be it...

With all due respect , as you likly know a lot about what you are posting...step aside and let others post...sometimes less is better.

Do no harm

[Kiril]

Originally Posted by Weekend cut easymoney

as you likly know a lot about what you are posting

He doesn't, therein lies the problem.

[44DCNF]

Just adding more to your list.


green sand
coconut coir
coconut water
diatomaceous earth
zeolite/pozzolan
biochar
composted chicken manure
peat moss

[dKoester]

I wish some of these people would becomes as beneficial as the microbes they preach about!!!!

[lawn2012start]

no problem. just trying to learn.

[green connect]

Dear god, please stop using the smiley face emoticon. Completely disingenuous.