Back UP! RUP's are not restricted because they cause "unreasonable adverse effects to people etc, etc". That is NOT correct.
Please make sure you understand what you're talking about before saying things like this in a public forum. The problem with making erroneous statements in a public forum such as this is that what you're saying isn't moderated for accuracy before it posts. So what we say might be misinterpreted as truth by someone who is equally or even more ignorant of fact, science, & law.
Any pesticide that caused all this unintended colateral damage to the environment, people, & pets simply wouldn't be registered at all. No chemical manufacturer is willing to risk that much exposure to liability.
Now on to the truth of the matter.
RUP's are quite often calssified as such for no other reason than they are intended for commercial (applied for profit by someone other than the property owner) use. This is frequently the sole decision of the pesticide's registrant often for marketing & potential liability reasons. In other words, Restricted at will. Not by law.
Many states will see "For sale to & use by commercial applicators" & immediatly turn the material into an "RUP". Toxicity has absolutely nothing to do with anything in this case. The manufacturer has decided they don't want homeowners & other unlicensed applicators using the material.
As a for instance, in New York State (not LI) my company has a .15% Dimension on fertilizer that is registered & packed for consumer use & sold through major retail stores. We also market .07%, .10% & .15% Dimension on fertilizer products to Commercial Licensed Applicators with the words "For Commercial Use Only" written on the label. These are all RUP's. Yet some are actually less than one half the strength as the non-restricted version that is packed for retail.
There are also some pesticides that are Restricted because of their concentrated mammalian toxicity &/or potential for colateral unintended environmental impact. If a person is licensed to purchase & apply theses prodcuts commercially, then there is little reason to go into how & why they're classified this way.
Please be certain to understand what we're posting about before making this sort of statement. I really wish that only licensed applicators were allowed to post here.
Attention Moderator: Making pesticide recommendations in some states is illegal unless the person making the statement is licensed in the state it is intended to be circulated & read. While this isn't an issue for Sean at this time, garbage like this could become a problem if nothing is done about it. Something to think about.
Private emails only. I never check the PM section of these message boards.
Thank You
Steve Jepsen with LESCO
sls247@lesco.com