Comparing Trucks

Discussion in 'Trucks and Trailers' started by crazygator, Jan 28, 2003.

  1. excel25

    excel25 LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 393

    FORD get the PSD, I pull a 20' enclosed and get 16mpg on the road. My helpers v10 gets about 6.
     
  2. ksss

    ksss LawnSite Fanatic
    Posts: 7,131

    Brickman,
    I don't take away from the thread and banter back and forth so this will be my last post on the subject. I will be in Billings, MT. from 02-14-03 to 02-17-03. If your interested we'll run em for time empty or I may have a 31' fifth wheel trailer in town we can load it up and run it that way. Makes no difference to me. Let me know if your interested and I'll get you my cell number. After the cryin stops, we'll go and trade your PSD in for something a little more competive. As the saying goes Brickman, "nothin but air and opportunity".
     
  3. Brickman

    Brickman LawnSite Bronze Member
    Posts: 1,249

    I aint trading my PSD in for any thing. Unless it be another PSD.

    And sorry I can't make it. Job won't let me.
     
  4. G. Moose

    G. Moose LawnSite Member
    Posts: 48

    I'm definitely partial to Cummins. For a tranny, I hear with Dodge that their sticks are better than auto. The sound cool too. But I also here vice versa with Fixed Or Repaired Daily. :D
     
  5. SpudsM15

    SpudsM15 LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 627

    Nobody likes the chevy 2500hd with the duramax?
     
  6. Bill Davis

    Bill Davis LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 397

    you dont really hear too much about them on the site so I guess not. When I drove one I just didn't feel like I was in a truck. It made me feel like I was driving a bigger version of a 1/2 ton. But, maybe thats just me. :)
     
  7. ScotLawn

    ScotLawn LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 309

    Wally,

    I'd go with the 250 psd 7.3 4x4 crew cab. the extended cab does not have any room for people to ride in and if you get in the back and shut the doors you will see. If you start having guys work iwth you, more leg room will mean less tired guys and harder working. Down side is it's longer so turning it takes more road. I'd get the short bed. unless your pulling a 5th wheel or goose neck, a long bed is too much. Now I will say if you have a tool box and a long bed it's nice for being able to close the tailgate with a 4 wheeler in the bed.

    As for the auto vs stick, it's all up to you. the stick does have more it's advantages in pulling but shifting all the time in traffic is a pain. When i get my truck, I should say IF, it will be a 250 4x4 xlt PSD Crew Cab short bed. By the time i get one the 6.0 will have the kinks out. Right now the 6.0 is too new for my taste.

    I will say that the 6.0 has more HP and TQ than the 7.3 and the 5speed auto is nice.

    Now the ford/dodge thing. My brother in Law has both. 2000 350 CC 7.3 and a 2001 dodge 3500 cumins. both sticks both 4x4. the dodge is nice and has a straight pipe on it so it sounds like a MACK truck. Power on both are about the same but I think it's a little more toward the cummins due to it being the 24 valve. I'd stll take the ford.

    Hope this makes it clear as mud.

    Scot
     
  8. rscontracting

    rscontracting LawnSite Member
    from nj
    Posts: 4

    The crewcab is the way to go you can unhook the trailer and use it as a family vehicle.The diesel is another must have if you plan on keeping it for a long time.It will pay it self off in fuel savings and resale value will be there if you run the miles up.I just drove to Florida and was able to get 650 miles on 32 gallons of fuel.I have a crewcab longbed 250 psd. I love it rob
     
  9. TaussigLawnCare

    TaussigLawnCare LawnSite Member
    Posts: 206

    dodges suck unless a cummins turbo fords suck no matter what and I think for a mowing truck the best around is about a 70s chevy but if you want something newer. Go with a 2500 HD chevy or gm they are big enough to tow anything and get better gas milage and are the most dependable and cheap to repair. I had a ford but about everything went wrong with it so I sold it for almost nothin and I have a 94 dodge I had to put a new motor in and then I have my 2 older chevys that work great and one has a plow that makes me 200 an hour lol when it snows
     
  10. Randy J

    Randy J LawnSite Bronze Member
    Posts: 1,124

    Hey Derek, how's Manhattan these days? Been a while since I've been there, but I love that town.
    As for the trucks, from the sounds of what you have, and currently own, I don't think it's the brand as much as the truck themselves, and maybe the care taken of them. While I've seen some "lemons" with every brand, I would have to say overall Ford or Dodge neither one suck. I would take a mid 90's Ford or Dodge anyday over a 70's GM for a work truck. While the motors may be simpler on the older trucks, they're not as reliable, nor efficient. I've had nothing but good luck with the Dodges, as well as the Fords I've owned. Might just as well say Powerstrokes are horrible because mine lost the serpentine belt the other night.

    Randy
     

Share This Page