Corn Gluten not labeled for crab grass control???

Discussion in 'Organic Lawn Care' started by upidstay, Mar 28, 2011.

  1. upidstay

    upidstay LawnSite Bronze Member
    from CT
    Posts: 1,289

    Just saw a bag of Bradfield Organics Luscious Lawns corn gluten 9-0-0. No where on the label does it say anything about crab grass control. Recomends 10lbs per 1000' for fertilizing (.9lbs of N), but not a word about weed control...
     
  2. phasthound

    phasthound LawnSite Platinum Member
    Posts: 4,567

    I believe that claim can only be made if the CG meets standards set by Iowa State's patent. Also, by not making that claim on the bag, the product may circumvent the need to have a pesticide license to apply in certain states.
     
  3. ICT Bill

    ICT Bill LawnSite Platinum Member
    Posts: 4,115

    at 10 pounds per 1000 you ARE just fertilizing, it has little to no pre emergent capability at that rate
    If you ever see it in a feed mill it has to be 60% protein minimum to be effective as a pre-M, the suggested rate by Iowa state Univ. is 20 pounds per 1000 minimum, their testing went all the way up to 80 Lbs per 1000 YIKES!
     
  4. ParadiseLS

    ParadiseLS LawnSite Member
    Posts: 76

    Bill, i remember seeing someone post here in a prior thread that 40lbs/k is the recommended app for pre-m viability. now i see you talking about higher N content than a 9-0-0.....

    i specifically looked for sources for app amounts, and government sites and others are talking about 10lbs/k, and that is generally the manufacturer's recommendation.

    1. can you help me out by showing a link to some of this information about applying 4x the recommended dose

    2. are the manufacturers and governments misleading consumers because they think all of us dolts will just spread it on like peanut butter and all the N will leach out and alter the ecosystems of the rivers and lakes?
     
  5. ICT Bill

    ICT Bill LawnSite Platinum Member
    Posts: 4,115

    HUH????
    I can't speak for governments and have no idea where you have gotten your information
    there is 17 or 18 years of testing data here
    http://www.hort.iastate.edu/gluten/
     
  6. HayBay

    HayBay LawnSite Senior Member
    from Ontario
    Posts: 846

    Paradise LS,

    the info you have heard is right.

    When they first brought out CGM for Weed supression it was said to use 25lbs/1000 ft.
    60% protien content is required in the CGM. Not a higher Nitrogen value.
    The effectivness of CGM as a supressant is based on amount applied

    10lbs/1000 = fert
    25lbs/1000 = supression capabilities

    The one thing with all the new ECO or Enviro products is that the amount of AI (Active ingredient) needed to work is getting higher and higher.

    From an environmental point of view these products are not reducing impacts but increasing them.

    If you want to use CGM as weed supression you will need to buy a forklift and many rat traps. No joke.

    Does CGM work consistently and effectively as weed supressant?
    I say NO.

    CGM is made from Genetically Modified Crops.
     
  7. JWTurfguy

    JWTurfguy LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 327

    Upidstay's comment should serve as a good reminder to pay close attention to what's in the products you buy, especially when it comes to organics. Sadly, it seems that especially with organics, there are so many snake-oils and deceptively marketed products that it makes finding good products that much more difficult.

    I'm not a big believer in corn gluten as a preemergent, but I know that plenty of other people are. That being said, if you're going to sell it as a preemergent application, make sure that it's labeled as such. Also, kinda makes you wonder about the rest of Bradfield's line if they're so willing to deceive with their corn gluten product, doesn't it??
     
  8. ICT Bill

    ICT Bill LawnSite Platinum Member
    Posts: 4,115

    I am not standing up for Bradfield although I know the folks that run it well. It is labeled as a fertilizer and at that rate that is about all you can expect. deception? I think maybe not
     
  9. Marcos

    Marcos LawnSite Gold Member
    Posts: 3,720

    Focus on building the turf's overall density.
    Ultimately, thick, healthy turf will be your best crabgrass & broadleaf control.

    Corn gluten meal @ 10 lb / 1000 is fine as a fertilizer.
    So are soybean, alfalfa or cottonseed meal all @ 15-20 lb / 1000.
    Distiller's grains has become the hottest deal going cost-wise at least in this part of the country.
    Gotta go w/ the flow!
     
  10. JWTurfguy

    JWTurfguy LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 327

    Ok, so I stand corrected. While most people who would be looking for corn gluten are probably hoping to use it as a preemergent, if the label doesn't actually claim it and the sales rep doesn't either, it's not deceptive. One would hope that an honest sales rep might make mention of it just in case, but either way, it's your job as the buyer to pay attention to what you're getting.

    Still, the point remains that when you're pricing out various suppliers of corn gluten, best to make sure you're comparing "apples-to-apples" in terms of labeled use and not just focusing solely on bag prices.
     

Share This Page