field test -- help!

Discussion in 'Lawn Mowing' started by JimK, Jan 30, 2004.

  1. JimK

    JimK TURF MAGAZINE Publisher
    Posts: 136

    Jim @ TURF magazine here.

    I posted this a while back ... not a single response. Does that mean there's noone in the group interested in this? Jezzz.

    ""Well, I'm looking for a pro who would be interested in doing a 3-month field test of a stand-on sprayer manufactured by L.T. Rich Products.

    The test report will be published in the magazine.

    They'd like it done in Indiana March-May.""

    Any takers?

    :confused:
     
  2. tiedeman

    tiedeman LawnSite Fanatic
    from earth
    Posts: 8,745

    Is this a hydroseeder or fertilizer/weed spray unit?
     
  3. JimK

    JimK TURF MAGAZINE Publisher
    Posts: 136

    It's a fert/weed sprayer. Pretty cool.
     
  4. tiedeman

    tiedeman LawnSite Fanatic
    from earth
    Posts: 8,745

    probably the best results then for response would to be post it in the pesticide/fertilization forum if you haven't done so yet.

    Got a pic or link for the product?
     
  5. SodKing

    SodKing LawnSite Bronze Member
    Posts: 1,648

    I'll test it in New Hampshire
     
  6. Yard Perfect

    Yard Perfect LawnSite Member
    Posts: 133

    I don't know what "stand-on" sprayer is.
     
  7. James Cormier

    James Cormier LawnSite Bronze Member
    from Ma
    Posts: 1,218

    I have 2 perma greens, and I would love to test that machine.

    Here's a little about me

    Been in lawn care 18 years, on my own for 10, Started small, grew way to big, then sold off to get back to small owner operator, that just does lawn care ( fertin & squirtin)

    I love the idea of these machines but I was very disspointed in the perma green, I sure you can search in here to find my complaints.

    You can call me at 1-877-653-7866
    Jim
     
  8. James Cormier

    James Cormier LawnSite Bronze Member
    from Ma
    Posts: 1,218

    Jim, Here's a question for ya.
    Why not run a turf mag like car/motorcyle mags? I guessing your income is from the ads so you dont want to say bad things about some machines. I feel that you are doing alittle disservice to us the end users by doing this.

    I read many motorcycle mags and if a manufactur comes out with a crappy product they rip it. AND the manufactur fixes it.

    Use perma green as a example, that machine has so many flaws right from the start, the end user is the R&D for that company cause every year they come out with a new machine. Some flaws are fixed only to have others show up on the new machine.

    Back when we were in the mowing business we bought a toro z355, what a mistake that machine was, if I got a chance to read some honest info then i would have never spent 10k on a mower.

    Just my thoughts.

    Jim
     
  9. JimK

    JimK TURF MAGAZINE Publisher
    Posts: 136

    Hi Jim,

    Here's the answer to your question: Our revenue is indeed from advertising ... but unlike other magazines, we have never shrunk away from telling the truth. The field tests we've done to date are published unedited (except for typos, etc). If someone finds a problem --- like the ones found with the Perma Green sprayer -- it's right there in the magazine.

    Now if we had a field test article which was obviously done by someone with an ax to grind, we wouldn't run it. But fair criticism is fair.

    My guess is that you don't read my magazines much ... or you'd know that we don't sell you guys down the river, ever.

    Also -- if I knew a piece of equipment was junk (and there is some junk out there) -- I wouldn't see any value in getting it field tested. Why give junk all that exposure?

    Example: should I do a field test using a Craftsman rider for commercial purposes? I don't think so. I used to have one. For mowing my lawn (small at the time) it was just fine. For commercial use, it's junk.

    Thing is, most of what the manufacturers in this industry offer is good, solid equipment ... so I have no reason to contemplate any disservice to you folks.

    There is no "tone" to this note ... I'm not offended in the slightest ... it is a fair question and I hope you feel as if this was a fair answer.

    Jim Kendrick
    President/Publisher
    TURF Magazine
    FARMING Magazine
    SUPERINTENDENT Magazine
    LANDSCAPE CONSTRUCTION Magazine
    FOREST PRODUCTS EQUIPMENT Magazine
     
  10. James Cormier

    James Cormier LawnSite Bronze Member
    from Ma
    Posts: 1,218

    Thanks,
    I do read your mag monthly, been getting it for years, I dont see too many field test for products though.

    I wouldnt expect you to test a craftsman rider for commerical, but if you do a test on a walker, why wouldnt you compare it to its compettiton?

    My guess if did that and had to pick a "winner" the loser in the test would pull there adv.dollars.

    Right?


    "Also -- if I knew a piece of equipment was junk (and there is some junk out there) -- I wouldn't see any value in getting it field tested. Why give junk all that exposure?" you said

    If its junk then call it out!! If you save 1 small company from spending there hard earned money on something that dosent do what it should, doesnt that make sense?

    Ive been reading these mags since the mid 80's they seem to be gettiing bigger and bigger with ads.

    BTW....hopefully your not getting a "tone" from me and yes....you give a fair answer.
     

Share This Page