Ford vs Chevy

Discussion in 'Industry Surveys & Polls' started by jslawn, Dec 20, 2010.

?

Ford vs Chevy

Poll closed Dec 21, 2010.
  1. 08 Ford F250 5.4L

    8 vote(s)
    36.4%
  2. 08 Ford F350 V10L

    5 vote(s)
    22.7%
  3. 08 Chevy 2500 HD 6.0L

    9 vote(s)
    40.9%
  1. jslawn

    jslawn LawnSite Member
    Posts: 65

    1) 08 Ford f250 (5.4l)
    2) 08 Ford F350 (v10l)
    3) 08 Chevy 2500hd (6.0l)

    Single cab 4x4 truck which would you choose to haul a 16ft landscape trailer with 2 walkbehinds and handhelds. Also needs to be able to haul scrape metal and haul heavy equipment when needed.
     
  2. bradseabridge

    bradseabridge LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 720

    Uncle has the v10 in an f-250 that engine is beast, got like 200k miles on it no problems never been to the shop. Gas mileage is something to be desired though.
     
  3. jslawn

    jslawn LawnSite Member
    Posts: 65

    Well we don't buy trucks for there mileage. That's what i have a car for. I want a truck that has the power to pull and carry whatever i need it to. The truck makes me money no matter what mileage it gets period.
     
  4. bradseabridge

    bradseabridge LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 720

    The v10 has a higher towing capacity than the diesel if I'm not mistaken. He tows a 30ft bumper pull camper trailer with it all the time and he doesn't think twice.
     
  5. soloscaperman

    soloscaperman LawnSite Gold Member
    Posts: 3,045

    You guys are funny what happens when he gets two ZTR's that 5.4 is going to struggle big time!!
     
  6. bradseabridge

    bradseabridge LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 720

    Umm what?
    Posted via Mobile Device
     
  7. WorldsStrongestLandscaper

    WorldsStrongestLandscaper LawnSite Member
    Posts: 243

    My F350 03 crew 6' bed 92500 mi and my F350 04 extra cab 8' bed 119,000 mi pull my 24' enclosed trailers with each a Z,a 48WB, and a 60 WB and probably 750lbs of extras (weed whackers,blowers,racks, saws, hedge trimmers,gas ect...). Pulls no problem up hills both ways!!!!! It doesn't sag nearly as bad as my 04 chevy 2500hd!!! Mabey 7-8 miles per gallon each!!! Pulls my 14000lb dump trailer with 7500lb tractor no prob either!!!BIG STEVE B CT STRENGTH WSL
    Posted via Mobile Device
     
  8. LibertyFarmLandscaping

    LibertyFarmLandscaping LawnSite Bronze Member
    from NE TX
    Posts: 1,064

    I would go with the V10. The gas mileage isn't going to be but maybe 2 to 3 mpg better with the 5.4. When you need the extra power to pull the heavy equipment you will be glad you did. The 5.4 will struggle when you get over appx 7k lbs.
     
  9. bc3xx0

    bc3xx0 LawnSite Senior Member
    Posts: 304

    I'd go with #3 just cause I am a Chevy guy. However, the fords are really pretty.

    IMO the 5.4l would be plenty to haul whatever you could fit on a trailer mowing wise. You'd probably hit the safe towing capacity of the trailer axles before bogging the motor down.

    Motor are like d*cks. Everyone wants a big one!!

    Just curious as to why you don't have a diesel listed???
     
  10. Triton37

    Triton37 LawnSite Member
    Posts: 24

    Originally Posted by some guy
    The heads and plugs were redesigned in 08-09 (cant remember exactly) to try to solve the problem. Anti-seize wont do any good (but wont hurt) because its not actually the threads that are the problem. There is a little porcelain tip covered in metal at the end of the plug that actually breaks off in the head when it gets full of carbon. All though you shouldn't have any problems (new design), if it were me I would pull them every 30k to inspect them to be safe. Also run regular gasoline, not premium, premium adds to carbon problems.

    Sometimes the tool works, sometimes it doesn't. It gets expensive when the head has to come off, and Ford usually wont help the customer out any.

    Correct,the heads were redesigned in 09' and no longer contain the shielded porcelain tip. There is no need to remove and coat the new design plug. It is nearly identical to the older style plugs in the pre 04' 2V 5.4L's.

    Also, the "tool" has never failed to work for me and I have extracted dozens of these broken spark plugs. It is true that the job becomes much more difficult after an individual has attempted to remove one of them by themselves without knowledge of the tool or the procedure.

    Falcon, I have not experienced the concern you were explaining with the COP ignition design. The coils have been very reliable, although they do fail. We have a "stress test" to diagnos them. I would like to know more about what you have heard in terms of the failure you were mentioning.

    Triton - Buy the 08' Chevy if you have to but find an 09' Ford or newer based on all the new quality upgrades Ford Motor Co. has implimented in recent years.
     

Share This Page