Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Organic Lawn Care' started by Keegan, Feb 1, 2008.
Has anyone used this product before
We had a discussion on humates, humic and folic acids in a thread in late fall, I'll have to try to find it.
I know golf courses in the north where there are snow mold problems use humic acid in late fall to bind nitrogen in the soil which lessens the snow mold issues.
Humates in general are something where less is more, too much binds nutrients in the soil and can actually cause problems rather than help
20 pounds per 1000 seems like a lot of product to me, but I am no expert
I have no experience with this particular product
I want to put a question out there about humic acid products.
what about how biologically active A product is? some say their's is better cause their's is more active some don't mention anything about that, is it even necessary that the humic acid is active? biologically speaking. does it matter?
Barry Draycott (techterra), Matt at (organic approach) and Tom J (living soils) know a lot more about this than I do.
I would like to know the difference between HUMATE and HUMIC ACID, is one dry and the other a liquid, are both just a fancy name for leonardite (almost coal)
I'll let one of them chime in before I show my ignorance on this subject
Far be it from me to try to explain humates, so I leave to others. Here's a sample:
Humates & Humic Substances
Bio-Correct Inputs for the Eco-Farmer
by Gary Zimmer
Organic matter, compost,humus, humates, humic acid and fulvic acid are all related to, and are parts of, decaying plant materials. These organic materials are food for soil life and a storehouse for minerals, energy and water. They also serve as mediums on which certain organisms can grow.
Research is proving what farmers have long known to be true: humic substances stimulate plant roots and soil life (mostly fungal populations), chelate minerals (holding them for future use by plants), improve absorption of minerals for root and plant use, and improve the effectiveness of herbicides. This article will explain the different humic products available and how they presently are being used, while Lawrence Mayhews detailed review of the current scientific literature on the subject is available in Humic Substances in Biological Agriculture (Acres U.S.A., Jan-Feb 2004)
Humate is a common term used to describe dry-mined carbonaceous materials found in areas where coal is mined. They are correctly called leonardites or oxidized lignites.
For many years the most commonly used humic product was a black liquid extract called humic acid, obtained by mixing a strong base liquid material such as sodium hydroxide, or more commonly potassium hydroxide, with a dry humate material. The black humic acid material (not really an acid the base extraction has a pH of 9-plus), usually a 6- or 12-percent solution, was most commonly mixed with fertilizers, mixed with liquid nitrogen sources for use in transplant solutions, or mixed with herbicides. Its high pH meant that it could cause the liquid mix to jell or precipitate out, thus careful mixing was required. Mixing it with phosphorus materials was a real problem in many situations. Besides its use in transplant solutions (where it is highly diluted and doesnt cause many problems), my favorite way to use humic acid is to mix it with liquid nitrogen sources. It provides an organic material for the nitrogen to hook to, therefore reducing leaching and loss of nitrogen and buffering the solution for more effective and efficient use. My observations indicate that a rate of one to three gallons per acre, depending on nitrogen needs (which can be reduced with humic acid use), seems to work best.
Fulvic acid, another extraction from dry humates, is truly an acid. It is an acid extraction and has a pH near 3. It can be mixed with any liquid compound without difficulty. It is a part of the original material, but quite different from humic acid. My favorite place to use it is in liquid fertilizer mixes, where it buffers the soluble fertilizer, chelates it, and improves its uptake by the plants. Another common use for fulvic acid is to mix it with herbicides. Besides acidifying the tank mix, which helps the effectiveness of the herbicide, it again also chelates and improves the intake of the chemical. Application rates are from one quart to one gallon per acre, depending on the crop and on the amount and type of fertilizer and chemicals used.
If humic acid is extracted with a base, and fulvic acid extracted with acid, that which remains of the original humate is a large molecule called humin, with a sponge-like ability to hold and absorb parts we leave behind have some real benefits for example, the calcium, trace elements and rare earths remaining when the fertilizer industry extracts phosphorus from rock phosphates. The same is true for the minerals, vitamins, hormones and other unknown compounds left behind when cytokinins are extracted from kelp. Wherever possible, why not use the whole?
As for humic substances in the last few years micronized compounds with added suspending agents have been showing up in the marketplace. This is the original humic material ground really fine. Its an expensive process, and the product is not foolproof, as precipitation of materials and spray nozzle plugging have occurred, but the idea makes sense. This material can be used anywhere that humic and fulvic acids are used. In my biological farming experience after many observations and much testing dry fertilizer mixes provide more flexibility and are better buys. They also allow a grower to balance the soluble and slow-release materials. Liquid fertilizers are water soluble they can leach, tie up in the soil, cause short-term nutrient imbalances, and fail to provide nutrients over the plants life. They have their place as a pop-up to get the crop out of the ground or as a foliar to give a boost, but not as a complete fertilizer program.
How, then, can humic substances and dry fertilizers work together? Ive tried bulk spreading dry humates on soils. Theyre dusty and hard to handle, and I struggled to find any measurable results. It makes sense to add humic substances to fertilizer materials to provide carbon, a buffering, chelating agent, and some microbial foods. Using the original raw material provides the most benefits for the dollar, but handling that black, dusty humic material seemed unworkable for most fertilizer blenders. In Australia, farmers and consultants are blending humates with natural phosphates, calcium, sulfur and trace-mineral materials, inoculates with beneficial organisms, and then adding molasses and
brewing the batch just like making compost. The natural humic material has a low pH and a large nutrient-holding capacity, and it feeds microbes. The results look good, and the process makes sense.
There is still a problem with handling. You certainly cant spread it down the row as with a crop fertilizer. The secret to fertilizing is to create a balance of nutrients, with concentrations where and when they are needed throughout the growing season.
To overcome these problems, we at Midwestern Bio-Ag have experimented with pelletizing humic materials and mixing them with calcium sources and rock phosphates. Its not an easy process, and because of the nature of the material, its difficult to keep it in a hard pellet form.
In our early attempts, something surprising occurred. We found that when a pile of humic substances is premixed with rock phosphates and allowed to sit for a period of time, the measurable soluble phosphorus content goes up! A reaction had occurred: the moist, low-pH humic materials were released, activating the rock phosphate (the same thing that was happening in the brew piles in Australia).
The beneficial results in the field have really been noticeable. My experience leads me to conclude
that humic materials belong in a mix with fertilizers. Not only can humic materials buffer fertilizers, but they also chelate, holding nutrients for longer plant use. Our next step in pairing humic materials with buffers is to make homogenized trace-mineral mixes using sulfate trace minerals paired with humic substances. This should also chelate the mineral for more efficient and long-term use.
wondering if you could comment on the article you posted?
the letter stated the company bio ag. I researched them and they say their product is made from carbonaceous shale or mud stone, they say it's peat from broad leaf fresh water plants , (i'm not sure if that's considered leonardite or not?) need to check that!
and they say it's superior to coal based leonardite from fossilized salt water reeds and sedge base,
Now ones fresh water broad leaf peat base and the others salt water reed and sedge.
Is it marketing or is there truth in their statement?
Any comment on this one?
Just found out about carbonaceous shale. (and theres many kinds not all making coal)
it's organic matter of all kinds , clay and silt minerals deposited from oceans and fresh water ways(lakes) from the carbonaceous period in time and fossilized, making coal and in that process of decomposition the humic rich materials raise to the surface making the top layers of coal, it being called lignite now that layer is oxidized by weather and is turned into leonardite. A humic rich shale or mud stone layer
and it's the humic rich shale's that are the source of humates and humic acid
( I think I said that right?) now I all ready knew most of that already but what I don't know is the difference in quality
my question is just about whether or not does it matter if it's a fresh water peat deposited shale or salt water? or if you can even tell?
please excuss my atempt at explaining this
My understanding of humates is that the material is decomposed enough that the parent material can not be determined. OTOH, everyone who supplies humates claims theirs is different and superior.
That being said, if you want humates, humic acid, fluvic acids, other soil amendments at fair prices.............ahem, you know who to call.
In my opinion, Terra Vita (which is a brand under Organic Approach) has the best humic acid and humate products on the market.
This is the same product that Barry sells...
If you're on the West coast, you can give us a ring too, as we have worked with their company for 3 years now. Wonderful people, excellent products, great company!