I've searched this topic and there are TONS of responses. Let's start with a mulched bed that has been edged a long time ago, but needing a refresh. http://www.howardshavens.com/images/Earth/Limon-Mulch-Bed-Before.jpg I'm used to taking a shovel and digging a new edge, raking out the dirt, and hauling it away. It takes time, effort, and a lot of grunt to do this. I've seen many products out there, and have narrowed it down to 3 choices. 1. Echo Bed redefiner 2. Walk Behind Bed Shaper 3. Stick edger I do not want to go with the first two choices because of the price. My question is, would a regular edger redefine a bed? I have no problem using a stick edger to redefine the "line", then dig out the soil. Is this recommended? I always thought a stick edger's purpose was to redefine beds...am I wrong?