In what way was I wrong? Please explain why you made a decision, based on a short post, and get all perturbed because you didn't get the right answer. These two respondents replied with questions, saying, in effect, they needed more info to make an informed decision in this matter. These are both good replies. You, on the other hand, responded right away with... If I didn't give enough info, why did you answer at all? Do I need to explain the entire conversation with the client, and the process of pricing a new job?