Thanks for sending that lead on take-all root rot, that's about the only one I've read that indicated it may be curable and how to go about it.
Yes, the fungus appeared a few inches in from the edge of the healthy grass. It came up after a couple of days of very wet weather. I've never seen any mycelium on the grass itself. I sprayed that area (plus surrounding area) heavily with the daconil after I took the picture and it appears to be dying back but could just be drying out.
Regarding the pH of the soil. I'm pretty stumped on that myself. The first sample was done by the extension service and included samples from about 7 different sites in the yard. Subsequent samples were taken close to the same spots and I used both a 'stick in the soil' meter (probably unreliable) and a soil test kit I bought that adds a chemical to the soil sample/water and turns color. Numerous samples from all over the yard give nearly identical readings using both methods. My guess is that the original samples to the extension service just happened to be from more acidic areas??? I'm going to repeat the soil sample using the extension service before spring and also get a report on the amount of nitrogen needed this spring. I know I didn't over apply the lime and went exactly by their recommendations. Much to the chagrin of my local feed store who I pressed for exact poundage to purchase, exact size of the property, exact spreader settings, etc., etc., etc.
In any case, I greatly appreciate the feedback. The lawn is pretty much dormant now and I'm going to try and figure this out before spring comes. I'll definitely send another sample to my extension service over winter. I still plan on re-soding the area in the spring.