I have both .. a 96 chevy 3500 dually with the 454 vortec and like someone said it works best under a load , it will fricking pull a house off the foundation lol , iTs a 2 wheel drive and i get 9 mpg loaded and 12 highway unloaded it has 87,000 flawless miles and i love it ,it seems like when you drive it its like driving a semi and you need a 40 acree field to turn it around , i also just got a 01 chevy 3500 8100 gasser with the ally tranny and now this thing has got some unbelieveable power . I get anywhere from 11 mpg down to 8 depending on the load only thing is about the allision tranny is you just cant jump in and go it has to warm up just a tad on cold winter mornings, i guess i like the 01 just atad better