CAT 257B vs DEERE 322

Discussion in 'Heavy Equipment & Pavement' started by Canon Landscaping, Mar 16, 2006.

  1. Canon Landscaping

    Canon Landscaping LawnSite Senior Member
    Messages: 259

    we have been demoing machines for the past week and yesterday we had a cat 257b and a deere 322 at the same time. The deere dealer showed up for the comparison but i have yet to even meet the cat guy and cat is not wanting to give me a price. here is what came of the comparison the deere will out push out lift out dig the cat and has better visibility but the cat has the pilots and smooth undercarriage the cat is also 2k more. So does anyone have opinions on the two machines or any info that might help.
  2. thepawnshop

    thepawnshop LawnSite Senior Member
    Messages: 387

    Iwas facedwith the same choice last year. When the cat dealer showedupm the firstthing he told me was that he wantedtotryand talk me out of their track machine. He said he came fromthe rental side of Cat before going into sales and they had a lot of problems with the undercarriage whenever a customer would use the machine on a side slope and it wasn't covered under the warranty and it was a VERY expensive.

    The Deere is designed to be used on side-sloping hills and I do it all the time with very minimul "pucker" factor. I am very satisfied with the is a tough machine and very reliable, but the cab is much more cramped than the cat. The pilot controls are nice as well, but I personally am not very good with them, though I am sure had I purchased a Cat, that would not be an issue.

    You have to go with what feels right, not always what costs the least...cause the lowest price machine is not always the best deal. Never mind the cat salesguy's bedside manner...if you like the Cat better, buy...but do ask about the undercarriag/side-slope issue. At this stage in the game, everyone makes a good's just the one that works best for you, which is why we demo them in the firstplace.

    Now Scag, tell him why he should by the Cat....
  3. 7 IRON

    7 IRON LawnSite Member
    from VT
    Messages: 227

    Deere's big selling point is how much trouble Cat has had with their
    tracks(asv manufactures)and the high replacement cost.Also,to adjust
    the tracks on the JD all you need is a grease gun.On the Cat,far more
    time consuming.:usflag:
  4. Qualey

    Qualey LawnSite Member
    Messages: 144

    I really don't see where all this talk of Cat undercarriage issues came from. We have had both ASVs and early Cats and have had great success with them on all kings of rocky sidehills to 4' deep mud. Yes, they are a pain in the ass to remove and we have replaced the front idler bearings in the 277 @ ~1000hrs, but thats how it goes with wear items. My 277 is hands down the strongest, most versatile machine I have ever used in this weight class.
  5. Digdeep

    Digdeep LawnSite Bronze Member
    Messages: 1,840

    I sneaking this post in during my planning period between math classes, but I have to chime in.

    I don't own a CAT 257, but I do own an RC50 and it has the same undercarriage that the 257 does. I used to sell Bobcat before going into contracting on my own and I bought the ASV machine over the Bobcat tracked machines for many reasons that I have posted on previous threads. I have been extremely happy with the durability and performance of the ASV machine and undercarriage. I do know that the CAT machine is rated for a 3-1 slope and I have NEVER had a problem working on slopes other than getting to a point that I thought the machine would roll on me. The tracks have never been thrown and I don't see any adverse wear. I can't speak for the CAT salesman, but I can imagine that any machine in a rental environment will see more abuse than a machine owned by someone. I also know that the Bridgestone tracks on the Deere machines aren't cheap either. I would ask them what they offer for track warranty. I know that ASV offers a 2yr 1000 hour warranty on their tracks, and the replacement tracks come with the same warranty for as long as you own the machine. I imagine that CAT offers something very close to ASV since ASV makes the undercarriage.
  6. Caribbean Breeze

    Caribbean Breeze LawnSite Member
    Messages: 60

    Dig Deep,

    The Cat 257B has an operating weight of 7560lbs with an operating capacity of 1615lbs @35%, the ASV RC60 has an operating weight of 6200 lbs and operating capacity of 1330lbs @35%.

    The Cat machine is better by 285lbs but it weighs 1359lbs more than the ASV (CAT IS 7559LBS, RC60 IS 6200LBS). I understand from a Cat Service Engineer, Cat runs the tracks tighter because of the extra weight.
    Also the weight distribution on the ASV is more even that on the Cat machine because the ASV is not built off a skid steer platform. The Cat machine is 6 inches more wide that the RC60. Asv is a little faster, Cat has a little more lift height etc. and ASV a little more ground clearance.

    Maybe the ASV machine's track will outlast the Cat? they put alot more weight on the same undercarriage....Maybe.....:confused: :rolleyes:

    I just ordered 3 new units (one RC60 and Two RC85's) from the ASV dealer, I will get them in April. I want people to put their trust in my services as I am a smaller contractor in Florida, based on this, I prefer to buy from ASV because they are a growing company that makes a great product. In the real world, how could I get a chance as a small guy in the site prep business by developers?, if I myself am afraid of smaller manufacturers. I think ASV has proven itself....

    Supporting smaller enterprise is key to economic progress

    Who god bless, no man curse:clapping:
    Caribbean Breeze

  7. Green Pastures

    Green Pastures LawnSite Silver Member
    Messages: 2,457

    I don't know all the numbers and statistics...

    but I own a Cat 257B and I'm very happy with it.

    VERY happy.
  8. gammon landscaping

    gammon landscaping LawnSite Senior Member
    Messages: 553

    the 257 is rated for a 3 to 1 236 with steel tracks will go all over that with no problem and save you 20 grand
  9. Tigerotor77W

    Tigerotor77W LawnSite Bronze Member
    from Germany
    Messages: 1,892

    Why not order the SR-70 or SR-80? (just curious, not saying that those were the units you should have ordered.)
  10. Caribbean Breeze

    Caribbean Breeze LawnSite Member
    Messages: 60

    The SR Series delivery times are very long, up to 3 months or so I was told.

    They look really great and the new undercarriage is suppose to be very good.

    I have a job lined up and could not wait. I hope to buy one late this year or next year because maybe I don't want the very first of the units....:)

    For this job, I needed machines with the lowest ground pressure and most ground clearance, when I start the job, I will send you some pictures and it alot of soft mush / mud. I also wanted a unit that was on the lean side in terms of weight compared to operating capacity. ASV has better horsepower to weight ratio.

    Caribbean Breeze

Share This Page