I think the scope of edging should first be determined. If the beds are in good shape, I mean if they have been edged on a regular basis and still have a good edge on them, then a stick edger will probably work.<p>If the beds are in good shape, you may need to edge out more material, and may want to think about something heavier. In the spring, I usually go all out and use a edging shovel and cut out a nice deep edge. Also, Im always reshaping the beds here and there (Every year it seems like i'm not happy with the flow/look of the lines) The deep edge looks real sharp then when I put mulch in. <p>Personally, I think the stick edgers are great for maintaining the edges during the year, but for that first spring one, I prefer to use a edging shovel and/or something a bit more beefier. <p>A couple of guys by me have those edgers that<br>mount on the front of your rider mowers. They seem to like them from what I can tell, but they look somewhat limited in use. It may be something to check out though, especially in a commercial application.