• Online Events For Landscapers!
    With GIE+EXPO cancelled, virtual education and product launches are filling up the fall. Check out dates for Caterpillar, Exmark, NALP, and more. Click here to learn more.

John Deere 2305 or Kubota BX2230??

Team_Yamaha

LawnSite Member
Location
Wisconsin
I currently have 2 John Deere 400's, both have 9 gallons of fluid in the tires and 75 lb wieghts in the rear whels and they can't climb the hills in my yard without spinning. So I am in the market for a 4wd compact tractor. I am looking at either the John Deere 2305 or Kubota BX2230. Which one should I get?? What are pro's and con's of each?? Thanks guys!!!
 

Smalltimer1

LawnSite Bronze Member
Location
Raleigh, NC area
The 2305 is replacing the 2210. You will probably find a better deal on a 2210 unless the dealer is really pushing the 2305's.
 

Smalltimer1

LawnSite Bronze Member
Location
Raleigh, NC area
Travis Followell said:
I'd go with the Kubota. Same quality as the JD if not better for less money.
But less features for the $$$. I went and looked at some Kubotas while getting some Snapper tune up parts Friday and quite frankly if I was Kubota I'd be embarrassed about putting a tractor together in such a wimpy fashion--the reason for the cheaper price.

The rear axle tube on the Kubota is smaller than the axle tube on my 1969 IH Cub Cadet 73 that is only putting out 7hp. The JD rear end also is much larger than the Kubota's. Broken axle tubes are not cheap to replace especially with how proud Kubota is on their parts....

The draft links on the 3 pt. hitch on the Kubota are like rubber bands compared to the JD. I wouldn't want to put too much weight on the rear of a Kubota for fear of bending and/or breaking them.

Component for component, JD has the better/tougher machine. Quality has a price--you get what you pay for, and this is especially true with the Kubota. The idea that just because something is Japanese made makes it better is bunk.

....and yes I know JD uses a Yanmar engine--but the rest of it is American made.
 

whitetail

LawnSite Member
Location
Montana
I too like John Deere better, in my area the dealer is easy to work with and are friendly. go look at old used equipment by both. I have found that John Deere looks better, fewer cracks/welds and better overall condition.
 

Mickhippy

LawnSite Platinum Member
I know you didnt list it and I also know there not very popular with many but what about the X595. Ive got 580hrs on mine and it runs great. Much better ride than the BX, smaller/lighter etc. I also beleive it has a lower C of G.

Anyway, just thought I'd put it out there!
 

LawnScenes

LawnSite Member
Location
Virginia
I'd go with the John Deere. I own a John Deere 3120 and a Kubota B7500 and love the JD...
 

Smalltimer1

LawnSite Bronze Member
Location
Raleigh, NC area
JD also has it for dealer support after the sale. Most Kubota dealers are fly by night, meaning if they have a few bad months they could be gone the next. The JD dealers are more stable and therefore will be there for you in the unlikely event that you need any non-PM related parts.
 

Foz

LawnSite Member
We used to have a Kubota BX2200, which is a similar sized machine without some of teh new upgrades, used it for commercial mowing, snow removal, and never had any trouble, we traded it 2 years ago for a B2910. The best thing since both manufacturers have good reputations is to weigh which dealer will provide you better service & select a tractor based on that fact. It doesn't matter which is cheaper, they are comparable machines, dealer service is the difference. That is how we select all of our equipment!
 
Top