1. Can’t make it to the GIE+EXPO 2017?
    LawnSite brings the trade show floor to your fingertips with our new GIE+EXPO 2017 Sneak Peek video series debuting now in the Lawn Mowing forum.

    Dismiss Notice

New Edger

Discussion in 'Landscape Maintenance' started by J & K Lawn Service, Jul 28, 2010.

  1. Lefet

    Lefet LawnSite Bronze Member
    Messages: 1,887

    Really nice work pitrack
  2. Runner

    Runner LawnSite Fanatic
    Messages: 13,497

    I strongly disagree with the above stick suggestions.
    DEFinitely go with a walk behind edger. I have wrote rather extensive posts on this very subject with many reasons why the walk behind is the best choice for a first and initial edger. Don't even consider the trimmers, string trimmer edging attachments because they won't cut an inch off the edge an inch deep.
    Now, as far as walk behind edgers go, dollar for dollar, the McClane is very hard to beat. They are very easy to use, and last several years. They are just an excellent edger for the money.
    While stick edgers are great for quick off the trailer edgings, they are not good for doing heavy edging like thick initial edgings, and they are not good for anything over 5 minutes. A walk behind is much more practical for these. It has the weight, and ease of operation. This is why I believe a walk behind is the #1 choice for having any ONE edger.
  3. pitrack

    pitrack LawnSite Bronze Member
    Messages: 1,048

    Thank you

    I disagree with your post. They won't cut an inch off the edge an inch deep? Are you talking about an inch into the yard or if it's over grown an inch over the concrete?

    If it's an inch over the concrete just get a shovel and shove it under the dirt until you hit the edge of the walk then go down it with the stick edger. Has worked for me very well, it cuts it off in strips. I personally would get sick of hauling a big ass walk behind edger around and killing your back unloading it from the back of a truck. Not ALL stick edgers will work well, but get a bigger more powerful one and I think that is his best bet. It's all in preference though, I would get sick of hauling the walk behind around especially if it's edges that don't need it real bad just need cleaned up.*trucewhiteflag*
  4. Runner

    Runner LawnSite Fanatic
    Messages: 13,497

    The back of a truck? OUCH! Nothing heavier than a shovel does in the back of a truck. lol But yeah,...I was commenting on the string trimmer for not cutting anything deep (OR wide, for that matter) and a stick edger cutting over an inch of vertical depth (practically). And with a wheeled edger, they are just much easier to use for cutting heavy edges. Instead of holding and pushing, you can walk down with essentially a finger and thumb on each handle. Also, the point made about the more than 5 minutes is a very valid one. Any complexes with long runs, we use wheeled edgers on. Oh,...the stick edgers have their place - they are quick and handy out of the trailer, and in many cases, even faster to use, but like I said, for any ONE edger, a wheeled edger is always the best first purchase. It does all of the above.
  5. pitrack

    pitrack LawnSite Bronze Member
    Messages: 1,048

    I agree with you man. Wheeled edgers do all of the above, just take longer than a stick edger on a weekly edging. It comes down to what the OP wants to do. If he wants to edge his accounts he has and keep edging them weekly, stick is the way to go imo. If he wants to edge other yards that never get edged, a wheeled edger would probably suit his needs.:drinkup:
  6. georgiagrass

    georgiagrass LawnSite Senior Member
    Messages: 970

  7. lawnkingforever

    lawnkingforever LawnSite Bronze Member
    Messages: 1,280

    I agree with Runner, a WB edger is the way to go. I own a stick edger and WB edger. While I don't carry the WB edger on my truck everyday like my stick edger, it is nice knowing I have it for really overgrown sidewalks. I also have a couple corner lots that have a huge amount of sidewalk frontage that I use the WB on. While it is all personal opinion, I believe a WB leaves a cleaner edge.
  8. Andover Landscape Co.

    Andover Landscape Co. LawnSite Senior Member
    Male, from Lexington,KY
    Messages: 573

    Both are good but the walk behind is a must have for first time edging.
    One you can do without the other you cant.
    So if it's your only edger it must be a walk-behind. I learned that from experience long before I read this post...

Share This Page