I completely agree. Sorry, Laner, but this is not the work of a legitimate graphic designer. I pointed it out in the other logo thread, but this is not the work of someone I would pay actual money, or take a freebie from, to design the branding face of my company. There really is no design skill being used here. The person is simply taking various elements and haphazardly putting them together. The fonts, graphic elements, and visual weight/balance simply are amateurish at best, and that, really, is the simple reality. #3 is the only thing close, and that one leads me to think it's a "sign guy" who is selling his or her self as an actual designer, which is quite common.