NH tc 26 vs. john deere 2305 vs kubota bx23

Discussion in 'Tractors' started by deerewashed, Feb 23, 2010.

  1. deerewashed

    deerewashed LawnSite Senior Member
    Messages: 883

    i found 3 great deals on these items they are all about the same price....but are 1 or 2 hundred more or less. what shoudl i choose. these are what each one come with...

    New Holland:
    26hp 164 hours
    2 buckets

    23hp 130 hours

    John deere 2305:
    24hp 116 hours
    12inch backhoe
    frontier flail cutter
    post hole digger
    box blade
    belly mower
    tow behind airator

    PS...just be used onsite for light duty stuff and also for loading mulch into gator.
  2. PonyExpress94

    PonyExpress94 LawnSite Member
    Messages: 60

    Do you have a supporting dealership for each brand in your area? If no to any of them, I would eliminate that brand right away. However, my personal choice would be the New Holland. I have a lot of seat time on a TC33 and a 1630 (later called a TC 29). The layout of controls are intuitive and easy. Excellent reliability to boot, great visibility even with a loader attached, good access to daily fluid level checks and regular service points.

    In addition, with the tasks you listed, the New Holland gives you the equipment you need without anything extra. Could you find uses for the extra equipment? Sure, but do you have room to store those attachments until you find uses for them? How does the price of each machine compare? Are all three tractors local to you so you can operate them and see which one you like best?

    Hope this helps.
  3. GLS

    GLS LawnSite Bronze Member
    Messages: 1,185

    Are these by any chance posted on craigslist and marked near $4,000?

    That deere in particular caught my eye because I saw a 2305 with backhoe and all the attatchements as well as a crappy tow behind aerator that they only wanted $4,200 for, and just yesterday I saw it posted in another city for $3,800.

    If so, be careful, it's a scam.
  4. jimshack

    jimshack LawnSite Member
    Messages: 103

    I wish you were closer, I'd give you a good deal on a JD 2305. It's got about 110 hours on it, hardly ever use it.
  5. djfanintn

    djfanintn LawnSite Member
    Messages: 60

    a couple of years ago I was looking at the 2305. I drove the 2320 and it was a much nicer tractor.

    you might look up some of the problems with the fan that cools the transmission down on that particular model. I am not saying it is a problem but I have seen a few guys that did have a problem with it.
  6. blackjack219

    blackjack219 LawnSite Member
    Messages: 6

    you too, i saw the same ad on craigslist, mine came up as being in putnam ct
  7. jimshack

    jimshack LawnSite Member
    Messages: 103

    that could be a problem with it if it's used in the woods or heavy growth. these little tractors were designed to be used in manicured lawns. the issue is the plastic fan built on the drive shaft to provide cooling for the trans. instead of using a true hydro cooling system in order to save costs on production. If I had known it's limitations before I bought I probably would have gone with the 2320 or more likely the 2520, but I let my wallet do the deciding instead of good ole research.:hammerhead:
  8. deerewashed

    deerewashed LawnSite Senior Member
    Messages: 883

    guess what all these are on craigslist except sadly the nh is gone:( i made my dicision to buy it and cant find it.......
  9. POPO4995

    POPO4995 LawnSite Bronze Member
    Messages: 1,208

    I bought my 2305 last year with 99 hours on it and let me tell you...I love the thing. For its size, it sure has power and I never run outta jobs for it! And fuel consumption is very good, barely uses fuel.:)
  10. Ducati996

    Ducati996 LawnSite Member
    Messages: 188

    Nothing to do with the cooling system itself -
    Same problem is found on Deere's 110 TLB, where all the vulnerabilities are exposed. Protective plates can be installed easily enough. Problem solved, the machines are still performers....

Share This Page