• Thankful For Your Family…. Business?
    Landscaping businesses are often family endeavors. While this can combine the best of both worlds (personal and professional), it isn’t always smooth sailing. Click here to read more.

ripping stuff out

MJLsLawnCareNmoreLLC

LawnSite Senior Member
Location
Shelby Twp., MI
Hey, I have a 15ft maple that a customer wants ripped out and replaced with a new one. It would have been taller, but it has been hacked down many times. The trunk diameter is like 9-10 inches. Do you guys think its possible to rip it out with a truck? (91' dodge ram 250) How big do you think the root system is? By the way the tree is still somewhat alive.
 

Lombardi

LawnSite Senior Member
Your Dodge probably can't handle it, but my Chevy could. Just kidding. You could try. I would cut down all but about 4' of the trunk. Then wrap a chain around a couple of times and pull. If the ground is still wet it would be a good time to try.
 

sgrprincees

LawnSite Member
Location
Fargo, ND
I don't think you can pull it out. 10 inches is pretty wide, my thinking is that if it seems strong enough that you think you could winch off it if you were stuck in the mud, you won't rip it out just by pulling hard.
 

JohnK

LawnSite Member
Location
Seattle
I tried pulling an alder stump that size with my Suburban and couldn't do it, even in 4 low there just wasn't enough traction (285x75 AT tires) to budge it.

It wouldn't hurt to try pulling it, but I doubt you'll get it out with a pickup.
 

polecat63

LawnSite Silver Member
Cut the tree down and grind the stump. No way you'll pull a 10" tree out with a truck.
 

landscapingpoolguy

LawnSite Senior Member
Location
Sparta, NJ
I pulled a 12- 15 ft white pine with the winch on my jeep the other day.....The winch pulled it clean out of the ground with no problems at all......8000lb ramsey rep...ill say the diameter was around 6 - 8 inches tho

Chuck
 
OP
MJLsLawnCareNmoreLLC

MJLsLawnCareNmoreLLC

LawnSite Senior Member
Location
Shelby Twp., MI
No i dont have 4 wheel drive, but i was planning on using straps instead of chains. I would just grind down the stump, but he wants another maple right in its place. Thanks for the help so far. By the way, do rental places have tree spades? About how much are they to rent?
 

Randy Scott

LawnSite Bronze Member
Location
Wisconsin
No way you're pulling a 10 inch Maple out of the ground. Not without looking like a redneck hillbilly and getting the rear-end of the truck off the ground. I doubt it would come out anyways.

Do it the right way. Cut it down, grind it out. Pulling stumps out of the ground with trucks is what makes this industry display it's "scrub" image.
 

newleaflandscape

LawnSite Senior Member
Location
Michigan
The only other way I would yank it other then cutting and grinding is bringing in a backhoe and digging around it and then hooking up a truck. That way you can cut off major roots. But by the time you do all that it would probly be cheaper to have someone just spade it out.
 
Top