Lawn Care Forum banner

Chickweed herbicide control test

4K views 9 replies 7 participants last post by  RigglePLC  
#1 ·
During a winter warm spell, chickweed clumps were dug up and moved to plastic cups inside for two weeks in a sunny window. Chickweed was treated outside with one spray. 6 different herbicides were compared. Chickweed plants were returned to the window for ten days. The plants were placed in order--most effective to least herbicide effects. Results were: most effective to least:

Surge, (lower left)
T-Zone (with surfactant)
Speedzone
a three-way, (upper left)
Confront
T-Zone, plain
UTC (untreated control)

Estimated rate of herbicide solution was calculated at about a half-gallon per thousand sqft. Lowest label herbicide rates were used.

Of course, Confront is no longer labeled for lawns, but some old label formulation was left over from past years.
Photo included, of course.

Image
 
#3 ·
Interesting. I'm a firm believer of adding adjuvant.

However last year got done burning on warm turf with celcius and mso. Rep said they now recommend just celcius dline over 85. I tried it and it seemed to do ok.

I add more oil type in dormant season to help with drift.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
#4 ·
After 15 days, the effectiveness of herbicides against chickweed as tested indoors were ranked as follows, most effective to least. Surge, Confront, T-Zone with wetting agent, a 3-way, Speedzone, and T-zone (plain).

Of course, Confront is no longer labeled for lawns.

Surge on left. Untreated control on far right.

Image
 
#7 ·
Thanks it awesome what you are doing, I mean the time and energy you're putting into carrying out this test is just inspiring, at first I though you were trying to play a fast one, even still I love it, can't just find the thank you button
personally I prefer to add more oil than normal. And I don't know if you might find this helpful.
http://www.scotts.com/smg/goART3/Howto/how-to-kill-chickweed/34300030
Posted via Mobile Device
 
#10 ·
Thank you. The surfactant was a retail product from a garden/nursery store. 80 percent non-ionic surfactant spreader-sticker, Bonide brand.

I still have confidence in Speedzone--it was still effective.

I am puzzled by the difference in T-Zone with surfactant and T-Zone plain. Last summer they seemed to be about equal in effectiveness.