This thread is old, but since it was brought back up I will add my two cents.
100lbs of lime is not uncommon in my area. Since I do mostly new seeding, I have learned to adjust my lime rates based on seed establishiment. I have found that rateas as low as 25lbs per K will reduce seed germination if applied at the same time as the seed in a surface application. If the lime is being incorporated into the soil, I can safely use the entire 100lb recommendation.
Lime's effectiveness is relative to the particle size of the liming material. The smaller the particles the faster it will work, but particle size doesnot reduce the amount of lime needed to provide the proper amount of calcium the soil needs. Lime recommendations are based on calcium requirements, not pH. Lime will raise the pH levels in the soil, but so will many other materials commonly found in fertilizers, includeing Magnesium,( Mandatory element in dolomitic limestone), which has 1.6 times the Ph raising effect as calcium. Potassium and sodium will also raise ph.
Lime should be applied based on incorporation into the soil and amounts used need to be lowered or increased according to that incorportion depth. Soil test results are usually based on either a 6-7or8 inch sampleing depth. It just makes sense that if your sample is for a 6 inch slice of soil that you lime recommendations are for that same 6 inch slice of soil, therefore if you are only appling the lime to the surface the amounts should be reduce. The standard rate is usually 15% of recommendation for every inch of soil incorporation. Surface applications should be 15% of the recommended amount since you are only appling the lime to the top one inch of the soil. This is where particle size come into a bigger role. Each particle of lime has the ability to nutralize appox a 1/8in radius around each particle. A 1lb particle will still just neutralize that same 1/8 in radius a micronized particle will neutralize. Finer grind materials such as the solu-cal or liquid lime will provide faster neutralization at lower rates, and will also translocate into the soil at a faster rate than normal ag or pulverized lime, but these products will not provide the necessary amount of calcium when applied at lower than soil test recommended rates. Also it has been stated many times on many websites that lime takes months or even years to work, but leaf samples of plants have shown lime to work its way into the leaf area of crops in as little as three days after a surface application of ag grade lime stone. It would appear that lime translocates a lot fast thru the soil than many would have us believe. Generally, with my applications I apply lime based on a three inch layer of soil ,or approx 45% of soil test recommendations for established lawns, and a 1 inch slice or 15% for a new seeding when the lime isnot being incorporated into the soil. This seems to work the best for me, but I suggest that you do your own experiments, starting on the low side of the limeing rates and work up to the point where you see the best results. You can always apply more lime if needed, but it is hard as heck to get rid of it if you over apply. My applications work like this.
New seeding
15% at time of seeding
45% as a followup approx 8-10 weeks after planting
40% approx 6 months aft second application.
new soil test in one year and apply full test recommendations.
New soil test every two years and apply as needed
Established lawns.
45% recommendation @first application
55% second application @ 6 months
New soil test at one year and applied at full recxommended rate.
New soil test every two years lime as needed
Once you have added all the lime that is needed, you will find that it will take very little to keep calcium levels where they should be, of course CEC playes a big role in how long the lime will stay around, as well as any other elements that are added to the soil.